Skip to Content

The 5 BEST Dairy-free Substitutes for Butter

Have you ever needed a dairy-free butter substitute for a recipe but were unsure of where to turn?

Cooking with dairy-free products can be challenging, so it’s important to know which ingredients will work as effective substitutes.

In this article, I explore the versatility of dairy-free butter, how to cook and use it in various recipes, and the five best dairy-free substitutes for butter.

Read on to learn more about plant-based cooking with dairy-free butter.

What’s Butter? Why Consider Non-dairy Butter?

Butter is a staple ingredient in many recipes, and it has been around for centuries.

With the recent emergence of non-dairy butter, however, more and more people are exploring different options when it comes to enjoying this mainstay.

Non-dairy butter has many benefits, including being plant-based and often containing a higher amount of healthy fats than dairy equivalents.

They offer similar flavor and texture compared to traditional butter—some non-dairy alternatives even deliver the same kind of richness that true butter does.

This makes them ideal to use raw or while baking cakes, cookies, bread, pies, and more.

Most non-dairy butter is vegan friendly, too, which gives them an added edge compared to regular dairy butter.

No matter how you intend to use them, you should find that they offer an excellent flavor experience as well as a wonderful way to enjoy classic tastes with more flexibility.

The 5 BEST Dairy-free Substitutes for Butter

If you’re looking for a dairy-free alternative to butter, you have plenty of options.

Here are five of the best substitutes that can be used in baking, cooking, and more.

1 – Coconut Oil

Coconut oil is a wonderfully versatile ingredient with so many nutritional and culinary uses.

It has a soft yet subtle coconut taste with a light texture that fits well into both sweet and savory recipes.

With its high smoke point, coconut oil is also excellent for cooking based as it can stand up to temperatures that other oils cannot.

In addition, its creamy texture makes it the perfect dairy-free substitute for butter in baking or to be used directly on toast or baked goods.

When combining with other ingredients like spices, lemon juice, and herbs, make sure to be generous because the flavor of coconut oil will not overpower them.

2 – Avocado Oil

Avocado oil has become a popular alternative to butter and other cooking oils in recent years.

Its light color, mild taste, and high smoke point make it an ideal ingredient for many recipes.

With its delicate, nutty flavor, avocado oil is the perfect alternative for savory or sweet dishes.

In terms of texture, it is much lighter than butter and absorbs much better into food, making it perfect as a marinade or finishing oil.

Unlike other oils, avocado oil does not require heating before use; it can be used on toast instead of butter for a creamy consistency and has even been used to substitute dairy-free butter in baking recipes, giving your desserts an extra layer of flavor.

3 – Nut Butter

Nut butter is a versatile and tasty source of protein, fat, and minerals like copper and magnesium.

Though commonly used to make peanut butter sandwiches, nut butter can offer much more than that.

From crunchy almond butter to mild cashew butter, nut butter come in a variety of flavors as well as textures which make them an attractive addition to not only sweet treats like baking or smoothies but savory dishes such as soups or stir-fries too.

Cashew butter is delicious spread on toast with crispy bacon and maple syrup for breakfast or stirred into a creamy curry for dinner.

Almond butter works wonderfully as a dairy-free topping for waffles and can be melted over roasted potatoes for extra flavor too.

Nut butter is great when looking for things to substitute dairy-based butter.

4 – Lard

When cooking with lard, a popular fat found in many traditional cuisines, it becomes immediately apparent why historical home-cooking recipes relied so heavily on this wondrous ingredient.

Lard has an incomparable taste and texture, as well as versatility that is hard to match.

Its rich flavor brings out richer notes in savory applications – perfect for pies and crusts, as well as sautéing or frying all kinds of meats – while also proving to be an ideal dairy-free alternative for butter in some recipes.

Though not suitable for every preparation, its high melting point makes it desirable when baking heavier cakes or hearty bread; just take care not to overpower it since lard has an underlying salty flavor.

All things considered, lard could very well be the unsung hero of fat cooking that deservedly finds itself back at the top of many modern chefs’ ingredient lists.

5 – Olive Oil

Olive oil is one of the most versatile ingredients available in the kitchen.

Its mild and buttery taste, coupled with its delicate texture, makes it the perfect addition to many sauces, salads, and dishes.

It is also an excellent dairy-free substitute for butter.

As a fat source, olive oil adds richness to recipes and keeps them moist while adding flavor—it’s especially good as a finishing oil or in vinaigrettes.

Depending on the variety of olive oil that you purchase, some have sweet floral notes with a slightly peppery finish; others are grassy and full-bodied with aromas reminiscent of fresh olives.

Discover what olive oil has to offer your cooking by putting this nutritious ingredient at the front and center of your next culinary experiment.


In conclusion, when looking for dairy-free substitutes for butter, there are many delicious and healthy options to choose from.

Whether it’s coconut oil, avocado oil, nut butter, lard or olive oil, all of these alternatives have something special to offer in terms of flavor and texture – so go ahead and get creative in the kitchen.

Experiment with different ingredients until you find the perfect combination for your specific recipe.

Yield: 1 Serving

The 5 BEST Dairy-free Substitutes for Butter

The 5 BEST Dairy-free Substitutes for Butter
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes


  • Coconut Oil
  • Avocado Oil
  • Nut Butter
  • Lard
  • Olive Oil


  1. Choose your preferred substitute from the list of options.
  2. Organize all of your ingredients.
  3. Use the proper substitute to cook your recipes.

Sharing is caring!

Skip to Recipe