Many people might not realize the critical role that superfine sugar plays in baking.
But if you’re trying to make something delicate like a meringue or mousse, it’s essential to use superfine sugar – otherwise your final product could lack the desired lightness and texture.
So how can you substitute superfine sugar when it isn’t available? Fortunately, there are a few options that can be employed when highlighting the sweetness in your next desserts without compromising overall quality and consistency.
From organic raw cane sugar to caster sugar, these five substitutes for superfine sugar will allow you to maximize the deliciousness of whatever’s coming out of your oven.
What’s Superfine Sugar?
Interested in baking something special? Superfine sugar is a versatile sugar, also referred to as bar sugar, that has many culinary uses.
It is finer than regular granulated white sugar and dissolves quickly which makes it ideal for making beverages or dressings.
Its texture is smoother and its appearance resembles sand.
Its finer texture ensures that your recipes don’t turn out grainy.
This sugar can be used for making meringues, fruity glazes, custards, sauces and frostings.
When used in baked goods super-fine sugar imparts the same sweetness but at the same time has a less noticeable effect on the finished product’s texture.
As compared to granulated sugar when combined with other ingredients superfine sugar dissolves faster.
If you require this type of high-quality sweetener for a recipe, take some time to search specialty stores or online retailers as most common grocery stores do not typically carry this type of product.
The 5 Best Substitutes for Superfine Sugar
As such, superfine sugar is often used in baking and beverage-making where rapid dissolution is desired.
However, it can be difficult to find in some stores as it’s not an everyday ingredient.
In these cases, here are five suitable alternatives to consider.
1 – Granulated Sugar
Granulated sugar, or table sugar, is the most common type of sugar and makes an excellent substitute for superfine sugar.
It is made from either cane or beet sugar and then ground into very small granules.
While not quite as fine as superfine sugar, it will dissolve quickly and easily when added to recipes.
You may need to grind it slightly with a mortar and pestle if you want an extra fine consistency.
Granulated sugar can be used in a one-to-one ratio for all cooking and baking needs in place of superfine sugar.
2 – Turbinado Sugar
Turbinado sugar is popularly known as “raw” or “unrefined” sugar, so it naturally holds more of a moist, brown-sugar texture.
The moniker suggests that even though it hasn’t been subjected to further processing, it’s had some amount of refining.
The result is a slightly larger crystal size than what you’d get with superfine sugar and one with a slight molasses flavor.
The size of the crystals can also vary from producer to producer, meaning that you might end up with something closer in texture to granulated sugar than superfine.
Since turbinado technically isn’t as fine as superfine and the crystals are bigger, use 1 teaspoon for every ¾ cup of the original ingredient.
3 – Brown Sugar
Brown sugar is a type of sugar that is made from white granulated sugar combined with molasses.
It has a more complex flavor due to the extra molasses and it also tends to be heavier and stickier than white sugar.
Brown sugar has a higher moisture content which makes it ideal for baking as it helps keep food items moist and soft, however, this is why you should use less when substituting for superfine sugar.
You can purchase light or dark brown sugar which refer to the color of the molasses used.
The darker the brown sugar, the stronger the flavor will be so opt for lighter brown sugar when substituting for superfine sugar.
4 – Maple Syrup
Maple syrup is a great substitution for superfine sugar.
It can be used in the same ratio as superfine sugar, but keep in mind that maple syrup has a distinct flavor that may alter the taste of the recipe you are using it in.
Furthermore, maple syrup can darken some light-colored foods so be sure to adjust your cooking time accordingly.
Maple syrup is an ideal replacement for dessert dishes like cakes, muffins and pies as well as some savory dishes like glazed root vegetables or marinades.
5 – Honey
Honey is a unique, natural sweetener that can act as a substitute for superfine sugar.
Its liquid texture, however, is quite different than that of sugar’s grainy, powdery feel.
Honey is often touted as being healthier than sugar since it contains some minerals and vitamins that sugar lacks, such as vitamin B6, thiamin and riboflavin.
It also contains antioxidants which can help reduce inflammation and disease-causing damage in the body.
Since honey is sweeter than sugar, however, it should be used thoughtfully so as not to overpower your recipe or beverage.
To replace a cup of superfine sugar with honey—without affecting flavor—use two-thirds cup of honey to one cup of superfine sugar.
Honey has the potential to affect doughs and batters differently from what you may expect; be sure to adjust other ingredients accordingly when using large amounts of honey in baking recipes.
For most baking recipes, the type of sugar you use can have a big impact on the end product, so it pays to know all your options.
Superfine sugar, with its delicate texture and flavor, makes an ideal sweetener for a variety of dishes.
Although it can be difficult to find in stores, there are many excellent substitutes available if you don’t have superfine sugar on hand.
Whether you need a replacement for dental work or want to make a light summer cake, try some of these five best substitutes for superfine sugar: regular granulated white sugar, granulated brown sugar, powdered instant coffee crystals (for baking) or vermouth (for cocktails), and liquid stevia extract.
With these reliable alternatives in your pantry, you won’t have to worry about last-minute substitution when the craving hits.
Enjoy the sweet taste of your favorite desserts and drinks — no fine-grained sugar required.
The 5 BEST Substitutes for Superfine Sugar
- 1 – Granulated Sugar
- 2 – Turbinado Sugar
- 3 – Brown Sugar
- 4 – Maple Syrup
- 5 – Honey
- Choose your preferred substitute from the list of options.
- Organize all of your ingredients.
- Use the proper substitute to cook your recipes.