Skip to Content

The 5 Best Substitutes for Pizza Stone

If you want to make and bake pizza in your oven, you need special cooking equipment known as a pizza stone.

Pizza stones are specially made pieces of ceramic that absorb heat well and distribute it evenly during baking, resulting in crispier crusts on pizzas.

When using a pizza stone, place the preheated stone in your oven, then put your pizza on it.

It’s important to note that pizza stones are not just used for making pizzas.

You can also use it on other things, such as bread, cookies, and even some roasted meats.

A pizza stone is a porous material, allowing heat to pass through the stone.

This results in more evenly cooked food.

It is also non-stick and can retain heat for a very long time.

This is why it’s possible to bake the pizza almost immediately after it’s removed from the oven.

A pizza stone can last for a very long time, given that you take proper care of the stone, but accidents do happen.

If your pizza stone has broken or cracked, don’t worry because there are many other alternatives to using a real pizza stone.

Here are 5 of the best substitutes for a pizza stone.

What is a Pizza Stone?

what is a pizza stone

As the popularity of cooking at home has grown, so too have the number of tools available to make cooking easier.

One such device is the pizza stone, also known as a baking plate.

Usually made from ceramic or porcelain materials, it is used to make many different types of flatbreads and pizza.

A pizza stone works by transferring intense heat from the bottom of the oven to the top of the crust, cooking it faster and more evenly.

It also helps keep moisture in to produce a crispier finished product.

The primary advantage is that the stone does not need to be preheated like a pan to work effectively; in fact, doing so can cause sticking.

Pizza stones are also safe for use with most types of ovens, unlike many cooking pans, which may only be used with certain types of ovens.

So the next time you bake a pizza, consider using a stone to make the process easier and more enjoyable.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Pizza Stone

Although using a pizza stone is a great way to make pizza, other options can also produce good results.

If you don’t have one on hand but want to bake some pizza for dinner tonight, try using some of these instead:

1 – Baking Steel

baking steel

Baking steel is your best option if you need a pizza stone substitute.

This product is designed to simulate traditional brick oven results at home.

The concept behind it is that this steel has great thermal mass and will absorb and retain heat well.

It’s also porous, which helps with heat transfer throughout to create a crispier, better-tasting pizza crust.

Professional chefs highly recommend it.

Baking steel is also easy to clean.

Just use some soap and water after each use.

By not using a traditional pizza stone, you can avoid excess smoke from your oven as well as the need to preheat.

Baking steel is one of the best options for baking at home.

2 – Cast Iron Pan

cast iron pan

A cast-iron pan can be an excellent substitute for baking pizza.

It’s particularly an excellent option if you enjoy making homemade or restaurant-style pan pizzas.

This particular style of pizza is known for its usually thick, crispy crust and soft center when prepared properly.

The best thing about using a cast iron pan in this type of application is that it’s flat, so you’ll only need to heat the oven once without any issues.

All you have to do is preheat your oven, coat the pan with a little bit of olive oil, position your dough over it, and then let the magic happen.

Use this pizza stone substitute for anything from barbecue chicken pies to classic pepperoni.

3 – Baking/Cookie Sheet

bakingcookie sheet

A baking or cookie sheet can be used to substitute a pizza stone.

However, these are best suited for thin-crust pizza rather than thick.

If you’re using this option, it’s recommended that the tray be preheated on the very top shelf of your oven.

Putting your pizza in this spot will ensure that your dough cooks quickly and crisply.

It’ll also help you create a crust that’s soft with lightly-browned edges.

Just keep an eye on it.

This is one of the easiest options to use, but it won’t produce results similar to using a stone or steel.

It’s probably the cheapest of them all, too.

4 – A Hot Grill

a hot grill

You can also use a hot grill as an alternative to baking your pizza.

It’s great for creating crispy crusts that are blackened, similar to the results you might find at your favorite Italian restaurants.

If you’re unsure how to do it, start by preheating your grill on low heat and lightly oiling it.

Then, place your dough on the grill and cook it for two minutes or until you see grill marks.

Flip it over, add your sauce and toppings, then put the lid down.

Grill that pizza starting with a cold grill is an excellent way to get crispier crusts in general – quite similar to using an actual stone.

5 – Pizza Pan

pizza pan

If you’re looking for a more affordable alternative to baking stones, consider using pizza pans instead.

These usually take the form of either aluminum or steel pans that can be found at most major retailers like Walmart and Target.

The benefit of using these is that they’ll conduct heat much better than thicker baking sheets.

When you use these, you’ll get crispier crusts that are evenly baked.

It’s also an inexpensive way to make pizza at home if you don’t have the budget for one of the other options.

There are many shapes and sizes available, so you might even find one that fits the size of your oven.

Conclusion

If you’re looking to find a substitute for your traditional pizza stone, any of these will be sufficient.

While it’s recommended to use steel or stone for creating high-quality, restaurant-style pizzas at home, any of these options will be fine for making lower-quality pies.

Just remember that it’s important to preheat whatever you’re using before putting your pie in the oven.

If you would like to learn more about baking techniques, feel free to check out some of our other articles.

We have a variety of pieces, so if you’re interested in baking, pizza creation, or even just a recipe or two, we’ve got what you need.

Sharing is caring!