Skip to Content

Best Pizza Pan Reviews 2024 – Top 5 Picks

Disclosure: Our editors independently review and test the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We receive a small commission from purchases made via some links on this website. We do not accept free products from manufacturers, and we never allow ourselves to be influenced by how much money we could make off a certain product.

Homemade pizzas are the best because you get to choose what toppings you like and also the type of pizza you prefer.

Some may like chewy pizza, while others may like a more crispy one. Whatever your choice may be, the type of pizza you want will depend on the pan you choose.

A pizza pan determines the softness, chewiness, or the crispness of a pizza. A pizza pan is made of either aluminum, stainless steel, or cast iron, on which the pizza base is placed and then cooked.

For Italian fanatics, the best pizza pan is what you should own in your kitchen. The best pizza pan will ensure that the crust and toppings are together cooked at the same time.

Pizza pans come in different sizes and different materials. It’ll be easier for you to choose a pizza pan once you’ve determined the size and type of pizza you usually prefer.

To assist you in choosing the best pizza pan, we have curated a list of the top 5 pizza pans you can get your hands on. Read and choose the best for yourself.

5 Best Pizza Pan Reviews 2024

1 – OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Pizza Pan

81yNCNbK zL. SL540

Amongst the many, this pizza pan by OXO Good Grips is our best pick because of its heavy-duty aluminized steel construct, the Swiss-engineered PTFE coating providing excellent non-stick properties and the prices it comes at.

This 15-inch pizza pan is a great choice for both beginners and professional chefs.

The commercial-grade material ensures even heating and great distribution, which is backed by the micro texted pattern on the surface for increased airflow.

The high-grade non- stick coating makes it super easy to slide the pizza off the plate and also for an easier cleaning process.

The pan is resistant to scratches, stains, or corrosion, and it’s sides have a square rolled edges for increased strength, rigidity, and durability.

This pizza pan is worth the purchase and won’t disappoint you with its performance.


  • Long-lasting non-stick coating
  • Lightweight
  • A Micro-textured pattern on the surface for airflow
  • Replacement guarantee by OXO for faulty product


  • Nonstick coating should only be hand-washed
  • Not well suited for a deep-dish pizza

2 – Good Cook 13 Inch Pizza Pan

91IV55scLpL. SL540

This 13-inch pizza pan is a good choice if you like your pizza to be crispy.

Made of superior quality materials, this pizza pan guarantees durability and even heat distribution.

It has a commercial-grade long-lasting non-stick coating that helps in smoothly sliding the pizza off the pan.

The base of the pan is perforated in the shape of a spiral that makes the pizza more crispy and also ensures good airflow while cooking.

Perforated pans let the fire directly enter through the holes and cook the base, making it crispy.

The sides of the pan are slightly lifted for easier handling. This pan makes a good medium-sized pizza every time.

The pan can be easily hand washed using warm soapy water.


  • Perforated base
  • Superior quality built
  • Long-lasting non-stick coating
  • Crispy pizzas every time


  • Not suitable for a deep-dish pizza
  • Direct fire contact may burn the pizza if not careful

3 – Emile Henry 797524 Square Charcoal Pizza Stone

71t619wetJL. SL540

This pizza stone by Emile Henry is built through the brand’s patent BBQ technology using all-natural materials.

It is a large size pizza stone measuring 14″x14″ which is a perfect size for family-sized pizzas.

This pizza stone can withstand really high temperatures of up to 930 degrees F and retains the heat for a long time.

It can be easily used on gas, natural wood grills, and charcoal. Its heat diffusion property gives an even heat distribution as you bake your pizza.

The stone’s glaze gives crispy crust pizzas with the right amount of heat.

An added benefit of this pizza stone is that you can serve the pizza on the stone itself and smoothly cut the pizza without fear of scratching or cutting the stone.

It is dishwasher save and microwave oven safe too.


  • Large size pizza stone
  • Pizzas can be sliced on top of it
  • Crispy crust pizza
  • Flame technology used to build


  • Heavyweight
  • Pizza can stick sometimes

4 – LloydPans 14x14x1.5 inch Sicilian Style Pizza Pan

61 O f5LIYL. SL540

If you love a deep dish pizza pan, then look no further because this pizza pan by LLyodsPans is the one for you.

Made from heavy-duty 14 gauge aluminum, this pan guarantees sturdiness with even heat distribution, giving you those Sicilian style pizzas at home.

The pan boasts of a unique pre-seasoned tuff-kite finish, which is a permanent coating resistant to sticking, thus eliminating the need for any extra coating such as Teflon.

It can withstand extremely high temperatures making it usable in really high heating devices.

The rims are double thick and flat, giving the pan extra durability and strength. The thick aluminum helps in baking faster than other steel pans.


  • Pre-seasoned tuff-kite finish
  • Deep dishpan
  • Faster baking process
  • Even heat distribution


  • Slightly expensive

5 – Stansport 16006 Pre-seasoned Cast Iron Pizza Pan

71s3KJXmQdL. SL540

This cast iron pizza is built to last.

Made from high quality cast iron, the pizza pan guarantees long-lasting performance with continuous delivery of delicious pizzas.

Measuring 16.5 inches, the pan works well for a medium to large-sized pizza.

The reliable cast iron construct allows for quick heating and evenly distributes the heat efficiently for top-class cooking.

The cast iron allows it to withstand really high temperatures making it safe to be used in really high heating equipment.

It comes with a pre-seasoned coating, giving it a durable non-stick properties. The coating allows the pizza to slide off from the pan smoothly.

There are two handles attached on opposite sides for easier and safer handling. The sides are slightly curved to give added rigidity to the pan.


  • High quality cast iron
  • High heat resistance
  • Quick heating
  • Two handles for ease of handling


  • Can be heavy
  • Non-stick coating may wear off


A top-performing pizza pan is necessary to bake finger-licking good pizzas at home. Pizza pans help in cooking the pizza with ease and give the right amount of crispiness or softness to a pizza.

Pizza pans come in different materials, sizes, and designs, each suited to make a specific pizza type.

If you are looking for the best pizza pan for your then your best pick should be the OXO Good Grips Non-stick Pro Pizza Pan because of its superior quality, resistance to scratch, long-lasting non-stick coating, and not forgetting the product guarantee that comes with it.

About The Author

Sharing is caring!