Skip to Content

Best Broiler Pan Reviews 2024 – Top 5 Picks

Disclosure: Our editors independently review and test the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We receive a small commission from purchases made via some links on this website. We do not accept free products from manufacturers, and we never allow ourselves to be influenced by how much money we could make off a certain product.

A broiler pan is one of the most crucial cooking equipment to have around your kitchen if you want to minimize as much physical work effort, and still knock up a heartwarming dish for your family.

Whether you want to bake, grill, or broil on your most trustworthy kitchen companion-oven, broiler pans, just make your cooking venture easy and effortless.

A broiler pan is designed specifically to meet the demands of preserving the nutrients and all other key minerals of any food items such as fish, meat, or even vegetables when placed inside the cooking oven.

The pan is also constructed with a peculiar hollow cut-out design to ensure it traps the maximum heat coming from the oven; hence, allowing the food to cook faster.

The number of broiler pan options in the market at present is innumerable, making it impossible to pick out the best one.

Hence, we present you with the top 5 broiler pans you can purchase at present.

5 Best Broiler Pan Reviews 2024

1 – Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Broiler Pan

71Gf5g0wDsL. SL540

If you are looking for a broiler pan that can handle your everyday broiling needs with optimal ease, the Whirlpool 4396923 may be your ideal cooking companion.

The pan comes with a separate roasting rack and a metal grid in addition to the standard broiler pan itself which makes your job of broiling almost any type of food items (vegetables, meat, poultry, etc.) on your oven extremely easy and uncomplicated. 

Also, not to forget the considerable amount of savings it does to your pocket expenditure as well.

The broiler pan is constructed with a stainless steel core and has a porcelain finishing that not only ensures the heat absorption mechanism is up to the maximum level, but also promotes optimum durability as well.

The non-stick coat feature of the pan also allows you to clean the surface easily with the hand itself.

The pan also has a horizontal vented design to ensure that the oil and other residue minerals from the food are drained off efficiently to the bottom.

The surface of the pan is also considerably wider than most counterparts to ensure you can place multiple items simultaneously.

Overall, Whirlpool 4396923 is one of the most efficient and durable broiler pans you can buy at present.


  • The build quality is extremely durable
  • Provides superior heat distribution
  • Compatible with a vast number of ovens
  • Good value-for-money


  • Cannot handle extreme heat settings
  • The broiler size can be a bit underwhelming

2 – General Electric WB48X10056 Large Broiler Pan

91tPtGU5NgL. SL540

Technically, the WB48X10056 broiler pan is designed as a genuine replacement part for a wide range of General Electric ovens.

However, it can be used effectively for almost any other type of ovens as well, making it one of the hottest (pun intended) options to consider.

Like most other broiler pans, the WB48X10056 is ideal for cooking up any type of food ranging from vegetables to poultry products as well.

In addition to that, it can also be used as an effective springform pan to take care of your baking needs.

The pan has one of the most prominent vented design on the surface that makes the process of draining excess fats from the meat extremely easy and also to ensure the food is cooked perfectly even on all sides.

The pan is made from industrial-grade steel that ensures the highest level of durability even when exposed to extreme temperature settings.

The pan has a non-stick porcelain coating to help you clean out the food residues with optimal ease. 

This broiler pan also has ample cooking surface that can support enough food items to care for any family-sized cuisine demands.


  • It is easy to clean
  • The vent design is effective for draining off fats
  • Ample of cooking surface
  • Extremely durable


  • The razor-sharp vent edges may cause inconvenience while handling
  • Coating peels off easily

3 – Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan

51SaEV%2B%2B8SL. SL540

The vast majority of the conventional broiler pan comes with a common distinct drawback in the form of limited heat capacity.

However, this is precisely where the Range Kleen broiler pan thrives on.

The BP106X is excellent and probably the best option if you are looking for a pan that can cook up your food in the least required time.

The Range Kleen broiler pan can withstand up to the maximum effective cooking temperature of 1,025 degrees Fahrenheit, making it an ideal pan for distributing the heat evenly as well. 

The pan is manufactured with a heavy-duty steel material that allows it to withstand such extreme temperature settings.

The non-stick porcelain coating also allows you to place almost any type of food items without worrying about the stains they leave behind.

The slanted grate design on the grilling surface is also sufficient for draining out the fats efficiently, and the intelligent blunt grate design on the surface also makes it easier to handle as well.


  • It is sold in a two-piece set
  • It has a high heat withstanding capacity
  • Extremely robust and durable
  • The unit is compact and light


  • The deep grate design can make it hard to clean at times
  • Less cooking space


Finding your ideal broiling pan can be a tricky venture to undertake, especially if you do not have the proper tools to research which products are equipped to meet your ideal requirements.

The above list provides some of the best broiling pans that can carry out almost any type of basic cooking needs ranging from simple frittata to baking cookies and cakes.

However, if you are looking for an all-rounder broiling pan that provides the best-value-for-money, and also ensures optimum broiling efficiency, the Whirlpool 4396923 makes for a compelling option out of the three cooking pans.

About The Author

Sharing is caring!