Skip to Content

Thickening Wing Sauce: Easy Guide to Flavorful Thickness

Wing sauce or Buffalo sauce that you make specifically for wings is a great way to add more flavor.

Many people simply use their favorite Buffalo sauce when they are cooking wings, but these can easily be made at home, and they generally turn out better than a store brand.

These can also be used as a dipping sauce or served over your wings.

The main ingredients that you need are butter, hot sauce, Worcestershire sauce, and vinegar.

You should not use store-bought vinegar because it will change the flavor of the sauce.

From here, you can add other items such as blue cheese crumbles or even curry powder.

To achieve the best texture, you should use unsalted butter and hot sauce.

The vinegar adds an acidic flavor, so you will want to add more or less of this, depending on how much heat that you want in the sauce.

In this article, we will cover how you can thicken wing sauce so that it has greater clinging power.

How to Make a Perfect Buffalo Wing Sauce?

how to make a perfect buffalo wing sauce

Buffalo wing sauce is not difficult to make. It can be made in just a few steps, put together within minutes, and then cooked for 15 – 20 minutes.

The first thing you need to do is cut up your butter into small cubes and place these into a pan on the stove over medium heat.

When the butter has melted, you will want to take your wing sauce, which can be purchased at stores or homemade, and pour it into the pan.

While you are waiting for this mixture to come to a boil, add your vinegar to the pan as well.

Once it is boiling, you will want to reduce the heat and allow this mixture to simmer for about 15 minutes.

While this is cooking, you can prepare your wings by cutting them into sections, placing them into a deep fryer or large pot of hot oil, and frying until they are done.

We recommend adding blue cheese crumble and even curry powder to your wings when you serve them for more flavor.

Common Mistakes When Making Buffalo Wing Sauce

common mistakes when making buffalo wing sauce

When making a homemade Buffalo wing sauce, you mustn’t make some of the common mistakes to have better results. Some of these mistakes are listed below.

Many people make the first mistake when they’re trying to make their own Buffalo wing sauce to purchase the wrong ingredients.

Many people purchase store-bought vinegar for their sauce, which can give it a strange appearance and alter your taste buds.

While it is still possible to make a sauce using the store brand vinegar, you may want to consider making your own, which we will cover below.

Many times, people rush to make their sauce that they do not add the ingredients properly.

It is important to make your own buffalo wing sauce to cook it slowly and at low heat so that all of the flavors can be blended together correctly.

If you simply stir your vinegar into a pan with melted butter without heating the mixture first, then you will end up with an unpleasant result.

Another common mistake that people make when making their own sauce is to not add enough hot sauce.

Many times store-bought sauces are too spicy, so if you simply try to duplicate this in the comfort of your own home, then you will be pleasantly surprised with the results.

Also, many people simply do not cook their sauce long enough, so if you are in a rush to get dinner on the table, consider making your wings after the sauce has already been cooked.

Otherwise, you will have an unpleasant meal.

How to Thickens Buffalo Wing Sauce?

how to thickens buffalo wing sauce

One drawback to the popular Buffalo wing sauce is that it tends to run off your wings and onto your plate.

So how can you thicken up your sauce so it will cling better? Here are some suggestions for making your Buffalo wing sauce thicker.

1 – Add Cornstarch.

One way to thicken up your Buffalo wing sauce is to add some corn starch.

When it first starts cooking, you will take 1/2 cup of water and mix this with about 1 tablespoon of corn starch.

Then slowly stir this mixture into the buffalo wing sauce as it cooks, careful not to leave any clumps.

If you want to use all corn starch instead of part water, you can do so as well.

2 – Let the Sauce Simmer.

Another way that you can thicken up your sauce is to let the mixture simmer longer.

While most cooks allow this to cook for about 15 minutes and then drain away some of the water or oil, so they have a thicker content, you can actually make it even thicker by simply cooking it for an additional 10 – 15 minutes.

3 – Don’t Use White Vinegar.

White vinegar is going to make your sauce too thin.

If you want to get a thicker consistency, it is best to use cider or balsamic vinegar instead.

Also, this will give it a much better flavor and aroma as well.

4 – Ketchup is Key.

If you want to make your sauce thicker, then one thing that you might want to consider adding is ketchup.

This will not only give it a flavorful taste but will also help to thicken up the mixture as well.

You can even add some when you are cooking the sauce to really allow all of the flavors to come together.

5 – Use Corn Syrup.

Also, you can thicken up your sauce by using corn syrup.

This is a sweet-tasting ingredient that will also give it a better appeal and texture.

Also, this will make your wings rich and sticky with flavor without being spicy, which makes it perfect for the whole family to enjoy.

Cornstarch is generally better for beginners, but corn syrup may be the way to go once you have made a sauce before.

6 – Use Roux.

If you want to thicken up your sauce a little bit more, then you might want to consider using some roux.

While it is true that this will add some extra flavor, this may not be desirable for those who are trying to cut back on fat or calories.

To make your roux, you will simply add some butter to a saucepan and allow this to begin melting.

Then you will slowly stir in one part of flour until it has been completely mixed together with the melted butter.

Next, cook this over medium heat to cook all the way through, stirring constantly.

This should take about 5 minutes or so. Then you can add this to your Buffalo wing sauce and allow it to continue cooking until you are finished.


In conclusion, Buffalo wing sauce is generally served hot with a wide variety of appetizers.

Also, the ingredients that make this type of wing sauce vary from region to region.

In addition, Buffalo wing wings are generally made with chicken flavors and are covered in hot or BBQ sauces.

When making your own sauce, it is best to make a large batch so you have some leftovers for the next day.

You have several different options that you can go with to make this happen.

Just try experimenting and see what works best for your recipe.

how to thicken wing sauce

How to Thicken Wing Sauce? Easy Guide to Thicken Buffalo Wing Sauce

5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course Cooking


  • Wing sauce
  • Whisk or spoon
  • Stovetop
  • Your preferred thickening ingredient


  • Prepare all the required ingredients and equipment in the article.
  • Select and follow your desired method to thicken.
  • Depending on your desired thickness, you can add more or less.
Did you make this recipe?Mention @EatDelights or tag #eatdelights!

About The Author

Sharing is caring!

5 from 1 vote (1 rating without comment)
Recipe Rating