Skip to Content

Can You Freeze Buttermilk Pie? Easy Guide to Freeze Buttermilk Pie

Buttermilk pie is a classic Southern dessert recipe. Spiked with vanilla, it is a creamy and luscious dessert that appeals to everyone.

There are many ways to make this pie, but one of the most common methods is simply using a store-bought frozen coconut pie crust and adding ingredients directly from the can.

The best part about making buttermilk pie is that it freezes very well.

Whether you are looking for an easy dessert item or just want to save time by preparing something in a day when you will not be able to serve it, this delicious recipe is the solution you have been looking for.

As with any other frozen dessert, buttermilk pie can be kept in the freezer for up to 3 months; however, it is best to thaw the pie overnight in the refrigerator.

When serving this frozen delight, make sure that you do so as soon as possible after removing it from the freezer, or else it may lose its creamy texture and will not be nearly as tasty.

In this article, we will explore the art of freezing buttermilk pie and provide you with some great tips on how to make it.

Choosing a Good Recipe for Buttermilk Pie

choosing a good recipe for buttermilk pie

The recipe for this spectacular dessert is rather simple.

Buttermilk, vanilla, and sugar are the primary ingredients you will need to make buttermilk pie.

You can even add a few other natural components such as lemon zest, chocolate chips, or candied pecans if you are looking for more flavors.

The truth about choosing good recipes for buttermilk pie is that you do not have to be a professional baker or pastry chef to make this fantastic dessert.

Even if you are a novice cook, it is very easy to follow a simple buttermilk pie and taste delicious.

Some people prefer using box mixes over-complicated frozen pie recipes since they are so easy to prepare.

You can find a few high-quality recipes that utilize box mixes at cookbooks stores and online.

Does Freezing Affect Buttermilk Pie?

does freezing affect buttermilk pie

The answer is that it depends.

If you can serve the pie shortly after removing it from the freezer, your dessert will taste great even if it has been frozen; however, if you let it sit in the freezer for longer than a month or two, then there might be some quality issues with your dessert.

When freezing buttermilk pie, it is best to take precautions to avoid quality issues after thawing.

First of all, do not allow the pie to sit out on the counter for longer than two hours, or it may begin to defrost slightly and change color and flavor.

Keeping it frozen until you are ready to serve it can maintain its texture and taste.

Secondly, it is best to use a container to fit the entire pie and keep it as cold as possible.

Place the container in a part of your freezer where temperature changes are minimal, and it will maintain its quality for longer.

Also, try to avoid using bags or containers with plastic linings since they might cause your dessert to sweat and lose flavor.

A good container would be made from something like glass or metal to insulate against temperature changes while also preventing the pie from being exposed to air.

How to Freeze Buttermilk Pie?

how to freeze buttermilk pie

If you have chosen a great buttermilk pie recipe and are ready to begin freezing it, here is everything you need to know about freezing buttermilk pie:

It would be best if you started by preparing your frozen pie for the freezer.

You can do this by wrapping it in plastic wrap and placing it in a zip-close freezer bag.

Ensure that you remove as much air from the bag as possible before closing it; otherwise, you might end up with a mess when you take it out.

In addition, you can put a layer of wax paper in between your pie and the plastic wrap so that the crust will not get soggy.

With your frozen pie properly wrapped, it is time to place it in the freezer.

As already mentioned, the best place for your pie container is a part of the freezer where temperature changes are minimal.

This way, the pie will maintain its quality for longer.

Don’t forget to label your pie so that you will remember what’s inside.

Depending on the recipe you choose, your buttermilk pie should be frozen for up to six months.

How to Thaw and Reheat Frozen Buttermilk Pie?

how to thaw and reheat frozen buttermilk pie

Here are some quick and easy steps you can use to thaw buttermilk pie:

First of all, you will need to remove the frozen pie from the freezer.

You may choose to take it out the day before or even a few hours before serving it.

When you have removed it from its container, wrap it up tightly in a damp towel or place it inside the refrigerator.

Then, just wait for it to thaw. When your pie is ready to be served, you will want to re-bake it to restore its color and texture.

This may take from 10 – 20 minutes, so plan. You can use the original crust or opt for a new one if you prefer.

Reheating also allows you to enjoy your dessert warm, just like when it was first baked.

To reheat, you would bake your pie at 375 degrees for about 20 minutes or until it reaches an internal temperature of 190-200 degrees.

You may want to cover the edges with aluminum foil while baking since this helps keep moisture in and prevents over-browning.

How to Tell if Buttermilk Pie is Bad?

how to tell if buttermilk pie is bad

If you have decided that it might be spoiled after freezing your pie for months, there are a few signs that indicate this may be the case.

When you open the container and smell your pie, it should emit a sweet odor; however, if instead of a sweet smell, your nose is greeted by an off one or even no odor at all – your pie may have gone bad.

If you try to cut open the pie and the filling is runny or watery, this is a sure sign that it has spoiled.

In addition, if you notice changes in color from pale yellow to a dark brown or even greenish hue – your buttermilk pie may be spoiled.

Most frozen desserts will maintain their quality for at least six months; therefore, if you have had the pie in the freezer longer than this, it is probably best to discard it and start over with a new one.

If you are unsure whether or not your buttermilk pie has gone bad, it’s always best to throw it out.

Conclusion

In conclusion, buttermilk pie will add a new flavor dimension to your family’s mealtime.

As you can see, making buttermilk pie from scratch is not as hard as you might have thought; by using a great buttermilk pie recipe and freezing it, you will be surprised at how easy this dessert is to prepare ahead of time.

What are some of your favorite recipes for buttermilk pie? Keep reading for more great homemade desserts to freeze or learn about making a homemade frozen fruit dessert.

Can You Freeze Buttermilk Pie? Easy Guide to Freeze Buttermilk Pie

Can You Freeze Buttermilk Pie? Easy Guide to Freeze Buttermilk Pie
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes

Ingredients

  • Buttermilk pie
  • Air-tight containers or Ziplock bags
  • Labels and markers

Instructions

  1. You can do this by wrapping it in plastic wrap and placing it in a zip-close freezer bag.
  2. Ensure that you remove as much air from the bag as possible before closing it; otherwise, you might end up with a mess when you take it out.
  3. In addition, you can put a layer of wax paper in between your pie and the plastic wrap so that the crust will not get soggy.
  4. With your frozen pie properly wrapped, it is time to place it in the freezer.
  5. Don’t forget to label your pie so that you will remember what’s inside.
  6. Depending on the recipe you choose, your buttermilk pie should be frozen for up to six months.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest

Sharing is caring!

Skip to Recipe