Skip to Content

Upgrade Your Drinks: 5 Top Club Soda Substitutes

5 from 1 vote Only logged in users can rate recipes

Have you ever wondered why club soda is such an essential ingredient in many recipes?

Well, this crystal clear carbonated beverage offers a special flavor and texture as well as nutritional benefits.

One way to use club soda is for a simple mocktail or adding to your favorite summer drinks.

Additionally, it can be used for marinading recipes such as wings and ribs- making the food even more flavorful.

Even though Club soda offers chefs the ability to bring that extra oomph to many dishes, there are substitutes you can use if it’s not available-so don’t worry if Club Soda isn’t accessible.

From sparkling water with just a pinch of salt to juices or non-carbonated beverages alternative, discovering the top five substitutes is easy and they’re sure to maximize your meal.

What’s Club Soda?

Club soda is a prominently carbonated drink that has many uses in cooking, cocktails and even as an alternative to plain water.

It’s also known as seltzer or sparkling water.

In its most basic form, club soda is made by adding carbon dioxide to treated water.

Sometimes salt, flavoring or sweetening agents are also added.

Club soda has the same basic flavor profile as regular drinking water but it often contains added minerals such as potassium sulfate, potassium bicarbonates and table salt.

These added minerals can add additional health benefits and create a slightly different taste than plain drinking water.

The use of club soda varies depending on what you are using it for — from flavoring cocktails to baking cakes or baking fish dishes.

It can be used to enhance the flavor of recipes or replace other ingredients like eggs for certain recipes that don’t require a rising agent (such as latkes).

Club soda also helps add volume and texture to batters and dough when used in place of traditional liquid ingredients such as milk or vegetable oil.

It pairs especially well with chocolate cake batter — just make sure to test out your measurements when you’re substituting club soda for another liquid ingredient so that you don’t end up with a runny mess.

When it comes to cocktails, club soda adds fresh bubbles and effervescence while still allowing the flavors of beverages mix together nicely — the addition of club soda makes the perfect finish for any drink.

In particular, vodka tonics are made with one part vodka and two parts tonic plus some lime slices topped off with some ice cubes — adding a bit of club soda definitely gives that extra boost in flavor.

And lastly, if you’re looking for an alternative way to stay hydrated without feeling like you’re being punished by drinking simple tap water all day long then try adding some club soda.

The 5 BEST Substitutes for Club Soda

Club soda has become increasingly popular as a drink mixer, as its flavor profile can help to balance out sweet and bitter flavors in cocktails.

But what if you’re out of the stuff? Luckily, there are several easily accessible substitutions that you can use to mimic the taste and texture of club soda:

1 – Sparkling Mineral Water

Sparkling mineral water is the closest substitute for club soda in terms of taste.

The effervescence of this type of water is usually simulated with either carbon dioxide or nitrogen gas.

It contains no added minerals, salt, or flavorings and often has lower sodium content than Club Soda.

The taste can range from neutral to slightly tart and it’s a great option for those looking to reduce their sodium intake while maintaining a flavorful canned beverage.

Just be sure the label reads “Sparkling Mineral Water” – some brands may call their product “seltzer” or “tonic” which will likely have added sugar, preservatives, and calorie content.

2 – Ginger Ale

Ginger ale is a sweet and bubbly soda that is flavored with ginger.

It can range from lightly sweetened to super-sugary.

Since it contains sugar, it should not be used if one is looking for a non-caloric or low-calorie alternative to club soda.

However, ginger ale has many of the same bubbles as club soda, and it’s perfectly safe to drink.

To replicate the flavor of club soda, you can use ginger ale as a substitute for your favorite cocktails or drinks — just make sure to adjust the ratios accordingly.

3 – Seltzer

Seltzer is carbonated water with no additives.

It’s the most similar to club soda, but it doesn’t have the same amount of minerals.

Since it has a neutral flavor, seltzer is best used when recipes call for club soda and mild flavor won’t be affected by what’s being added to it.

A great thing about seltzer is that you can customize it with your own mix-ins like juice or fruit for sparkling fruit water.

4 – Carbonated Juice

Carbonated juice is the perfect option if you’re looking to add a bit of flavor to your drinks.

While it can be used as a substitute for club soda in cocktails, this option is particularly great in mocktails and other alcoholic-free recipes.

You can simply pour any juice into a carbonated beverage machine or use store-bought bottles for convenience.

Make sure to check ingredient labels before making your purchase, as many carbonated juices contain added sugar and artificial ingredients you may want to avoid.

Some of our favorite options include cranberry, pomegranate, apple and orange juices.

5 – Tonic Water

Tonic water, like club soda, is carbonated water and it also contains quinine.

While this may be an acquired taste, it can be helpful if you’re making a commonly made beverage such as a gin and tonic.

Since tonic water contains quinine and club soda does not, the taste of the finished drink will differ somewhat.

However, it is still considered one of the best substitutes for club soda due to its similar carbonation level.

As with any other substitute for club soda, always tasting test your beverages and make adjustments accordingly to achieve desired results.


After having examined the five best substitutes for club soda, it is important to note that the best option for you depends on the flavor and usage desired.

Carbonated water offers similar health benefits with the unique benefit of being free of artificial sweeteners and chemicals if you choose to purchase unsweetened varieties.

For a sweeter alternative, ginger ale works well in cocktails and as a flavoring agent for other beverages.

If you are looking for health benefits, unsweetened sparkling mineral water is an excellent choice, as it can be enjoyed without any added sweetness or preservatives like its carbonated counterpart.

Last but not least, tonic water is ideal for those looking to replicate a more classic club soda flavor in their recipes without added sugar or ingredients.

No matter which substitute you choose, making sure to use freshly-squeezed citrus juice will ensure maximum reflection of flavors in your libations.

The 5 BEST Substitutes for Club Soda

Recipe by Kimberly Baxter Course: Substitutes

Prep time


Cooking time


Total time




  • Sparkling Mineral Water

  • Ginger Ale

  • Seltzer

  • Carbonated Juice

  • Tonic Water


  • Choose your preferred substitute from the list of options.
  • Organize all of your ingredients.
  • Use the proper substitute to cook your recipes.

Did you make this recipe?

Tag @eatdelights on Instagram and hashtag it #eatdelights

Like this recipe?

Follow us @eatdelights on Pinterest

About The Author

Sharing is caring!