Skip to Content

How Long Does Cherry Pie Last? [Shelf Life Guide]

Cherry pie is a tasty dessert that many people enjoy. A Cherry pie is a pie with a cherry filling.

There are many different ways to make cherry pie.

Cherry pie is a dessert that can be enjoyed by anyone who likes the taste of cherries, butter, and sugar in their desserts.

If you are looking for how long cherry pie lasts, this blog post will be of interest to you.

We will discuss how to store cherry pie and how long it lasts in the fridge or freezer.

How to Store Cherry Pie?

how to store cherry pie

Cherry pie is probably one of the most popular desserts in America. And for a good reason.

It’s delicious with its tartness and sweetness, plus it has a beautiful crust on top to boot.

To store cherry pie:

Place your pies inside an airtight container (coffee cans work well) or place plastic wrap directly over the surface of each pie before putting them into any refrigerator storage bin.

Placing something like aluminum foil over these containers is helpful because it blocks out light that can cause fruit to spoil more quickly than usual.

One of the more popular methods is using an aluminum pan with freezer wrap.

This should take around 24 hours so place them on a baking sheet first if you want to do this without too much hassle later on (plus making sure they don’t touch each other since frozen stuff touching one another will cause problems).

To save space during storage, use plastic bags instead of containers like Tupperware because these need to be sealed well.

Another way to store cherries is by freezing them whole if you want them for a later date or anticipate not being able to eat the entire pie before it goes bad in your fridge.

You could also slice and freeze these pieces so that they’re easier to use when baking with them, but this method won’t last as long since all of the juices will escape from inside.

How Long Does Cherry Pie Last?

how long does cherry pie last

One thing about the holiday season has always been the abundance of fresh pies.

Whether it be apple, pumpkin, or cherry, one thing is for sure – we all love pie.

But how long does a cherry pie last? We have to wonder if any food can beat its shelf life.

A properly wrapped and stored frozen cherry pie will keep for up to 8 months in most cases.

For best results, though, you should store your pie in the fridge.

So for all of you who wonder how long cherry pie lasts, know that it should be stored at a temperature below 40 degrees Fahrenheit or if the storage area is less than 35% relative to humidity.

There’s no likelihood of water damage. Otherwise, refrigeration is recommended.

In general, though, the shelf life will vary depending on what type of crust (pie shell) was used, whether sugar has been added, how much butter (or shortening), etc.

If there’s cornstarch, this could extend its lifespan since it absorbs moisture and prevents sogginess.

But generally speaking, a good rule-of-thumb is about 5 – 6 days before any signs of spoilage start showing.

Most supermarkets keep the pies on a shelf-life of about three to five days.

This is only true for refrigerated (not frozen) varieties, however.

So if you’re looking to have one that’s still in perfect condition after dinner rolls around and your guests want dessert, we recommend buying one with the longest “sell by” date possible or make it yourself.

How to Tell if Cherry Pie is Bad?

how to tell if cherry pie is bad

The best way to tell if the cherry pie is bad is by looking at the filling color.

If there are any brown or black spots, it’s possible that your cherries were on a shelf for too long and lost some of their natural moisture content.

The next sign could be what appears as bubbles in the pastry when you cut it open.

The final sign of a bad cherry pie is when you take the first bite.

If it tastes watery or slimy, then your situation may be direr than initially thought, and caution should be taken before consuming any further bites.

If none of these signs are present in your slice of pie, then congratulations.

You have an excellent batch on hand that can last up to 6 days if stored adequately after cutting.

It’s best not to consume any fruit-based product past this point without consulting with an expert or professional chef about what other steps might need taking care of for optimal storage methods.

That being said, please enjoy the rest of your evening knowing you will wake up tomorrow morning with a sweet tooth satisfied.

how long does cherry pie last

How Long Does Cherry Pie Last? Does Cherry Pie Go Bad?

5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course Shelf Life
Servings 1 Serving


  • Cherry pie
  • Air-tight containers or Ziplock bags
  • Labels and markers


  • Read the guide thoroughly to learn how long it lasts.
  • Label your container with the content and date and keep track of how much you’re using!
  • Make sure to store in an airtight container in a cool, dark place (pantry or fridge).
Did you make this recipe?Mention @EatDelights or tag #eatdelights!

About The Author

Sharing is caring!

5 from 1 vote (1 rating without comment)
Recipe Rating