Skip to Content

Best 4 Slice Toaster Reviews 2024 – Top 5 Picks

Disclosure: Our editors independently review and test the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We receive a small commission from purchases made via some links on this website. We do not accept free products from manufacturers, and we never allow ourselves to be influenced by how much money we could make off a certain product.

A fresh toast simply transforms a lazy Sunday morning into a starting point for being an energetic player with all family members, right from the breakfast table (source). Its crispy sound and luscious taste have no match.

Nevertheless, it can be challenging to make sufficient toasts (source) in the least amount of time.

With a 2-slice toaster, doing so in a short period is almost impossible. If this is the case with you, it is the right time to switch to a larger and efficient 4-slice toasters.

With a 4-slice toaster of nice quality, making sufficient toasts (recipe) for all members takes 50% less time than what it takes with a 2-slice toaster.

A 4-slice model is not only efficient but also versatile enough to give you anything right from bagels to standard sandwich breads.

These models give out consistently golden breads whose crispy taste absorbs the attention of family members regardless of their age or likes.

They can fulfill diverse preferences such as pure standard toast or toasts that are crunchy from outside and soft from inside.

Above all, the pleasing aroma of hot toast with butter or waffles makes it easy to pull them out from their beds.

This is only possible with the right toaster model. To get it, it is essential to review the best models.

Thus, we shall review five top 4-slice toasters by understanding its different features.

5 Best 4-Slice Toaster Reviews 2024

1 – Cuisinart CPT-180 Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster

71t8AKzrInL. SL540

The Cuisinart CPT-180 is for those who need smart toaster features at the most competitive price but with a reliable brand name.

It features a classic retro feel throughout its consistent compact size for occupying less countertop space.

Its brushed stainless steel with polished chrome and black accents is an ideal toaster material.

Thus, this classic model can mix with any kitchen décor. However, it goes well maximum with the silverfish kitchen décor.

The toasting performance seems to be customer-oriented and up to the mark with several useful settings such as Bagel and Defrost.

The Bagel setting is a quite useful, as it enables leaving half of the bagel chewy while toasting the remaining half.

There are separate controls for a pair of slots, which enables you to prepare two sandwiches at once with different settings and time.

Thus, you can keep bagels on one side for toasting and defrost pancakes on the other side.

The shade control setting gives a comprehensive range of browning possibilities to personalize any slices of bread.

There is a handy dial for it, which is an adorable temperature and time control. However, it is a friendly innovation here in terms of shading.

These long slots are wide enough to fit a variety of items for toasting, including thick and thin French toast, pastries, and frozen pancakes.

There is also HI Lift lever for taking the lever up for pushing a slice out for quick removal using fingers. Once the toasting is done, the breads and lever come up.

Last but not the least; a crumb tray makes your maintenance job easy. With these controls and options, you not only can toast quickly but also gain a complete control over your morning toasts (source).

Thus, this one is our favorite toaster, as all its features have a positive impact! 


  • It’s sturdy.
  • Flexible with several setting options and ability to fit uneven bagels.
  • Easy for clean up and maintenance.
  • Affordable high-end model.


  • It’s quite difficulty in proper winding.
  • Clumsy lever feel.

2 – Cuisinart CPT-440 Touch to Toast Leverless 4-Slice Toaster

71 RY7P2B0L. SL540

This Cuisinart model seems to be a modern mix of elegant design and advanced digital technology to make your home look ultramodern.

This combination makes it one of the most intuitive 4-slice toasters.

Unlike other toasters in the market today, this one comes with a unique and advanced feature known as the motorized lift.

This automates the lifting and lowering of slices.

With a single button press, the motor securely and silently pushes down the slices into the slots and even upwards when toasted.

Therefore, in this model, the lift replaces the levers.

Once the toasting cycle is over, a beep sound occurs and the motor pushes the bread above the slots for easy reach.

These long slots are also wide enough to fit in a slice, French toast, pancakes, bagels, and pastries. Thus, this smart toaster delivers performance with truly robust but friendly features.

The stainless steel body comes with two separate control panels through which you can toast two different sets at one time, each with different settings. There are three standard settings namely, Reheat, Defrost, and Bagel.

Then, the shade control setting is now on a digital screen but provides the same set of browning options as in the aforementioned model.

Unlike some other toasters, there is an accurate countdown timer to inform you when the slices are toasted.

Clean up is easy with the removable crumb tray. The cord wrap beneath handle the unpleasant power cords when the toaster is not in use.


  • Consistent outcome.
  • Technically advanced design and toasting functionality.
  • Flexible with several toasting options.
  • Cord retainer.


  • The slot is not very long.
  • It takes a while to toast.

3 – BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster

This one is a classic oval model with accents in stainless steel.

Its selling point is perhaps its convenient design making it quite simple to store the device with the cord wrap when not in use.

Although light in weight, the toaster boasts a sleek build that matches with almost any décor.

The slots with auto-adjusting guides are wide enough to fit thicker slices or bagels but are apt enough to fit even a thin slice without it sliding down.

On the other hand, the high-lift lever ensures that the toasted breads are easily accessible.

While there are just two toast settings namely, Bagel and Frozen, they are capable of managing the toasting span for giving an ideal outcome.

Simply hitting the Cancel button pops up the toasts before they are burned inside the slots.

Another commendable feature is the crumb tray with a drop-down ability and is in the front instead of in the rear. This makes cleaning easier than other models.

The detachable tray glides smoothly for instant cleaning. It also averts the crumbs from falling on the countertop. This keeps you at peace, as there is no risk of a mess.

There are shade settings too in the form of shade selector knob.

It controls each side of the device so that it becomes possible to get the right outcome as per each member’s preferences. The knob is unmistakably numbered.

There are levers too to give that extra lift safely to reach the toasts. All controls are easy to access, which makes toasting convenient while in a hurry.


  • Lightweight, durable chrome, and stylish.
  • Convenient to use and clean.
  • Flexible enough to fit a slim or an oversized bread.
  • Perhaps the most affordable.


  • No alert sound or light when finished.
  • Occasionally slower than other toasters.

4 – Hamilton Beach 4 Slice Cool Touch Toaster (24121)

81YSoBM3jfL. SL540

This one is another versatile toaster to consider with a cool exterior surface.

There is a setting for having crunchy and soft bagels, perfectly browned toasts, and cooked frozen waffles.

Regardless of what you toast, the exterior of this model remains cool for you to store or move the toaster from the countertop.

Another unique and commendable feature we think is the set of special frozen settings.

These settings are Frozen Bagel and Frozen Toast.

The latter gives more time to the food to defrost and heat, while the former gives more time to toasting a specific side.

Thus, the Frozen Bagel setting facilitates preparing English muffins, buns, and frozen bagels. They are toasted right in the first time.

With these special toasting settings and a browning dial, your breakfast becomes a bit crunchy each morning. The slots are big enough to accommodate thick pieces.

It is praiseworthy to find that each toaster side functions independently. This helps in making a light toast on one of the sides and dark on the other.

While toasting a muffin or a bagel, the auto boost feature pushes the items out for easy removal.


  • It looks stylish.
  • Flexible enough to accommodate thick and thin items, offer various heat settings, and toast frozen foods.
  • Highly affordable.


  • It’s a bit heavy.
  • Effortful cleaning, as not all crumbs get onto the tray.

5 – KRUPS KH734D Breakfast Set 4-Slot Toaster

811FZDHtZnL. SL540

We feel that this toaster is among the reliable 4-slice toasters in terms of durability and settings.

The flashy retro design and brushed steel body give it a pleasant look, while the dual controls for four slots and four standard options for each make it a versatile model.

The options include bagel, reheat, toasting, and defrost. 

There is a shade setting with the 6-point browning control available separately for slots.

The toaster has two crumb trays that are removable and maintainable individually.

The high lift lever facilitates removing the slices out easily without burning yourself. Slots are wide and large to accept any size of the slice and foster more even browning.


  • Stylish design.
  • Even and both side toasting.
  • Flexible enough to offer different settings.
  • Convenient.


  • It requires sometime to get used to.
  • Uneven browning of sides.

What to Look for When Buying a 4-Slice Toaster

There are a few main features or factors to consider for selecting the right 4-slice toaster for your particular needs.

Usage Requirements

You should first start by asking yourself the manner in which you would like to use a 4-slice toaster. If you prefer having more control over the toast functionality, a model with extra in-depth controls and settings is ideal.

You may want to toast different breads in one round. In this case, a model with dual controls is ideal. These controls keep different settings for each slot as per the bread type to be toasted.

There are settings such as bagel, defrost, keep warm, and reheat. You can choose them as per your usage plan. If you do not want to use all four slots every time, consider having a minimum of two independent controls to avoid heating all slots simultaneously.


This is the second factor to consider even before the design and look. It is unwise to choose a sleek looking model only to know that it will not last beyond one year. Thus, ensuring durability is indispensable.

Would you choose a high-end toaster that shall last for several years or a simple model that simply can get the work done? While the output is same in both the cases, a few models are sturdier than the others are, although they are pricier too.


This factor is on top priority for many toaster buyers. This is because this equipment will typically be a lasting fixture on a kitchen countertop, which will keep the overall appearance enhanced.

Toasters are available in retro and contemporary designs, which you can choose from as per the kitchen’s décor. Many prefer a cool touch exterior for safely handling a hot toaster and storing it quickly in its place after usage.


Stainless steel is dirt resistant and durable but prone to fingerprints and scratches. However, with a plastic housing, fingerprints disappear after some time. A glossy chrome body is likely to show more such prints. Thus, a stainless steel with plastic accents matching the décor of your kitchen is ideal.


Most people also prefer a retracting cord to store the toaster easily. This frees up some countertop space. They also like to have a tray that collects all crumbs and pieces falling while toasting. This makes it easier to clean the toaster.


Choosing a 4-slice toaster is what we propose for families whose members cannot stay without those crispy morning toasts. Having one such 4-slice model saves much time for doing other things. However, choosing the wrong one takes much time and money.

Thus, it is essential to check out the reviews and choose as per your requirements. While most toasters look same, some features make each of them different. Here, we hope this post helps you to choose the right one.

In conclusion, our favorite pick is the Cuisinart CPT-180 Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster. Not only it comes from a reliable brand, but also the price is very competitive. It also offers various custom control such as 6-setting browning dials, dual reheat, defrost and bagel buttons with LED indicators.

About The Author

Sharing is caring!